Thanks for the added info. Where did you source your Everflex top?
Sunbeam Specialties show just the pebble finish for the soft top boot cover. I have been told this was the original finish.
However, Sunbeam shows the tonneau covers to be either the pinpoint vinyl or the crush grain vinyl (would this perhaps be the Haartz or Everflex?). While the soft top gets folded into the back compartment I can see where the thickness of the material would become an issue. However for a tonneau cover, do you not want something thick since it is just stored in the boot (trunk) when not in use?